Tully Fisher, Take 2

So the Tully Fisher plot in the previous post is great and all, but wouldn't it be nice to have the ability to make a scientifically useful plot instead of just using Illustrator?

Yes.

After a few email exchanges with Marla Geha, I obtained the data she used to make the plot in Geha et al. (2006). And here's the first draft of the useful plot:

The grey dots are the sample galaxies that Marla got from the literature (see Figure 7 in her paper for a color-coded version), and the ones with errors bars at the bottom are her sample. The red stars, on the other hand, are our simulated galaxies. The galaxies used were: h204, h239, h277, h285, h516, h579, h590, h603, and h986. Chris claims he's working on h799, so that should appear shortly. For h516, I used the run with the new star formation recipe because it matches much better.